Payton Tolle Greenville Drive Pitcher

       
 
Age: 22
Born: November 11, 2002
Birthplace: Yukon, OK
Height: 6-6
Weight: 250
Bats: Left
Throws: Left
   
Drafted: 2nd round, 2024 by BOS
How Acquired: Draft
College: Texas Christian
High School: Bethany (OK)
ETA: 2027

Photo © Kelly O'Connor
Pronunciation: TOLE-ee
First Pro Contract: July 29, 2024 (BOS)
Signing Scout: Chris Reilly
Signing Bonus: $2,000,000
Rule 5 Draft Eligible: December 2027
MLFA Eligible: November 2029
   
Pro Debut: April 8, 2025 (Greenville)
Added to 40-man: -
MLB Debut: -
Service Time (1/25): 0 days
Options Remaining: 3 (0 used)
Contract (2025): MiLB contract
   
Twitter: @RolleTolle49
Instagram: @rolletolle49

 
 
 
 
 
     
  Scouting Report & Links      
         
  Physical Description: Huge frame with minimal remaining projection. Looks all of listed height and weight.

Mechanics: Throws from a low three-quarters arm slot. High leg kick. Really drives off his back side and gets elite extension (7.4 feet or more). Has a very low release height. Arm action works, but has a slight stab behind. Very deceptive delivery in large part due to how close to the plate he releases the ball.

Fastball: 93-95 mph, tops out at 96 mph. Pitch has life up and both vertical and horizontal movement. Has shown premium bat-missing ability, even when used almost three-quarters of the time in college. Pitch plays well above its velocity. Command is a work in progress and control is only average. Has the traits that make you think he could gain velocity on his fastball in pro ball. Potential plus-to-better offering.

Sweeper: 82-84 mph. Long, horizontal break. Primary secondary pitch that evolved from a sweepy slider at 78-82 he threw in college. Needs to develop more consistency with the offering and the confidence to rely on it, but flashes bat-missing ability Potential average offering.

Slider: 86-88 mph. Short, horizontal cut-slider. Has more depth on occasion. Solid bite. Potential fringe-average offering.

Changeup: 88-90 mph. Inconsistent feel and shape. Uses very sparingly. Work in progress. Potential below-average offering.
  Career Notes: Mother was a member of Wichita State's golf team and father competed in track and field for Oklahoma State. Transferred to TCU after spending his first two years at Wichita State, where he was a standout on both the mound and at the plate as a power-first 1B/DH. Was a top five finalist for the John Olerud Award as the nation's top two-way player as a sophomore. Named Big 12 Pitcher and Newcomer of the year at TCU in 2024, where he began to focus solely on pitching. Led the Big 12 in K/9 and was 12th nationally in that stat. Named to 2025 Spring Breakout roster.

Summation: Wide range of outcomes from a left-handed reliever to a middle of the rotation starter. Very unique pitching prospect given his size and delivery. Could have some untapped potential, as he has only began to focus exclusively on pitching in his junior season. His extension would grade near the top of all pitchers in pro ball. Misses a ton of bats with his fastball even though it sits in the low-to-mid-90s. Needs to improve command and control and develop his secondary pitches to stick as a starter, but has a relatively high floor as a fastball dominant left-handed reliever. Breaking balls both show potential, but changeup lags behind. Type of arm that you want to bring into the player development system with some standout traits to build on.

Note: This page will be updated with a complete scouting report after the scouting team has seen the player in regular season game action.

Links
Red Sox select Payton Tolle with 50th overall pick (7.14.24)
Spring Training Video (3.18.25)

Scouting Report Update (4.19.25)
 
   
     
    Pitching Stats                                          
  year team lg level org age w l era g gs sv ip h r er hr hbp bb so whip k/9 bb/9
2022 Wichita State AAC NCAA --- 19 4 6 4.48 13 12 0 66.1 79 38 33 7 6 22 49 1.52 6.65 2.98
  2023 Wichita State AAC NCAA --- 20 9 3 4.62 15 14 0 85.2 81 49 44 9 5 19 97 1.17 10.19 2.00
  2024 TCU Big12 NCAA --- 21 7 4 3.21 14 14 0 81.1 57 30 29 6 7 37 125 1.16 13.83 4.09
2025 Greenville Drive SAL A+ Bos 22     stats                            
   
     
  Advanced Stats & Splits
   
     
  Awards   SoxProspects.com Awards  
  2022 Frisco Classic MVP
2023 All AAC
2024 Second Team All-American
  2025 SoxProspects.com Pre-Season All-Star 
SoxProspects.com  Pitcher of the Week (April 21-27, 2025)
SoxProspects.com Player of the Week (April 28 - May 4, 2025)
 
   

   
     
 
 
 
     
 
Copyright © 2003-2025 SoxProspects, LLC
All Rights Reserved.
email: info@soxprospects.com
SoxProspects.com is not affiliated with the Boston Red Sox,
Worcester Red Sox, Portland Sea Dogs, Greenville Drive,
Salem Red Sox, or Major League Baseball.
.